2015年ACCA考試模擬試題
Professional Level – Essentials Module,
Professional Accountant
1 (a) (i) Three Kohlberg levels
At the preconventional level of moral reasoning, morality is conceived of in terms of rewards, punishments andinstrumental motivations. Those demonstrating intolerance of regulations in preference for self-serving motives aretypical preconventionalists.
At the conventional level, morality is understood in terms of compliance with either or both of peer pressure/socialexpectations or regulations, laws and guidelines. A high degree of compliance is assumed to be a highly moral position.
At the postconventional level, morality is understood in terms of conformance with ‘higher’ or ‘universal’ ethicalprinciples. Postconventional assumptions often challenge existing regulatory regimes and social norms and sopostconventional behaviour is often costly in personal terms.
Level 1: Preconventional level
Stage/Plane 1: Punishment-obedience orientation
Stage/Plane 2: Instrumental relativist orientation
Level 2: Conventional level
Stage/Plane 3: Good boy-nice girl orientation
Stage/Plane 4: Law and order orientation
Level 3: Postconventional level
Stage/Plane 5: Social contract orientation
Stage/Plane 6: Universal ethical principle orientation
(ii) The level that Jack Mineta operated at
The evidence from the case suggests that Mr Mineta operated at the preconventional level. Although he seemed lessconcerned with punishment, his actions were strongly driven by the incentives of financial rewards suggesting a rewardsorientation consistent with preconventional thinking. He seemed prepared to ignore internal control systems (‘I’m in thisjob for what I can get for myself – big risks bring big returns and big bonuses for me.’). The internal control systems at
Global-bank placed clear limits on traders’ behaviour in terms of limits and exposure to the highest risk derivativeinstruments. Mr Mineta was unconcerned about compliance with controls and prevailing rules would have suggestedconventional thinking. Had he complied with the internal control constraints, he would not have lost the large amountof money. Nor would he have made the large prior profits but these were manifestly not sustainable. Miss Hubu’scomment that he ‘didn’t believe in right and wrong’ excludes any suggestion that his ignoring of rules was driven bypostconventional assumptions.
(iii) Stage most appropriate for a professional bank employee
The most appropriate level of moral development for Mr Mineta in his work is stage 4 within the conventional level (level
2). This level stresses compliance with laws and regulations rather than the 3rd stage which is about compliance with
norms to gain social acceptance.
Stage 4 is concerned with legal and regulatory compliance and the moral right is that which is the most compliant withprevailing regulatory systems.
[Tutorial note: it is possible to argue for other stages. Credit should be given for this only when robustly defended withevidence. Unsupported assertions should not be rewarded.]
(b) FIVE typical causes of internal control failure and the performance of Global-bank
There are several possible causes of internal control failure. The UK Turnbull report (in paragraph 22) gives examples ofcauses of failure but this list is not exhaustive.
Poor judgement in decision-making. Internal control failures can sometimes arise from individual decisions being made basedon inadequate information provision or by inexperienced staff.
Human error can cause failures although a well-designed internal control environment can help control this to a certain extent.
Control processes being deliberately circumvented by employees and others. It is very difficult to completely prevent deliberatecircumvention, especially if an employee has a particular reason (in his or her opinion) to do so, such as the belief that higherbonuses will be earned.
Management overriding controls, presumably in the belief that the controls put in place are inconvenient or inappropriate andshould not apply to them.
The occurrence of unforeseeable circumstances is the final cause referred to in the Turnbull Report. Control systems aredesigned to cope with a given range of variables and when an event happens outwith that range, the system may be unableto cope.
Tutorial note: accept other, equivalent explanations or references to other governance codes if valid. Study texts makereference obliquely rather than as a ‘list’ to learn. The above points can be expressed in different ways.
Time allowed
This paper is divided into two sections:
Section A – This ONE question is compulsory and MUST be attempted
Section B – TWO questions ONLY to be attempted
Do NOT open this paper until instructed by the supervisor.
During reading and planning time only the question paper maybe annotated. You must NOT write in your answer booklet untilinstructed by the supervisor.
This question paper must not be removed from the examination hall.
The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
-
心理諮詢師健康心理學要點:肥胖與減肥策略
減肥屬於以減少人體過度的脂肪、體重為目的的行為方式。適度減重可降低患肥胖症的風險,也可提高有肥胖併發症的患者的健康水平。下面是小編為大家整理的心理諮詢師健康心理學要點:肥胖與減肥策略,歡迎閲讀,希望大家能夠喜歡。一、肥胖症定義:如果軀體攝入了過量的熱...
-
2016年中級經濟師《保險經濟》第七章模擬題
2016年中級經濟師考試時間為十一月五號,考試就快來臨,以下是本站小編精心為大家整理的2016年中級經濟師《保險經濟》第七章模擬題,供參考學習,希望對大家有所幫助!想了解更多相關信息請持續關注我們應屆畢業生考試網!第七章工程保險一、單項選擇題1.在全部承包方式...
-
2015註冊消防工程師考試《案例分析》考點分析
一級消防工程師案例分析:汽車加油站建築防火案例分析注意事項(一)加油站是指具有儲油設施,使用加油機為機動車加註汽油、柴油等車用燃油並可提供其他便利性服務的場所。(二)埋地油罐是指罐頂低於周圍4m範圍內的地面,並採用直接覆土或罐池充沙方式埋設在地下的卧式...
-
中級經濟師《房地產專業知識》第一章複習重點
導語:在中級經濟師的考試中,關於《房地產專業知識》的第一章相關內容大家都知道是什麼嗎?下面本站小編為大家整理了一些重要知識點,需要複習的小夥伴們一起來看看吧。第一章房地產經濟基本理論1、房地產與其他財產、資產、商品等的最大不同是位置固定、不可移動。...